Practice Areas Reported by Attorneys at This Office
These areas come from individual attorney profiles and may not describe every service offered by the firm.
Client Reviews
Share Your Experience
Your feedback helps others choose the right attorney.
Many people have positive experiences with this firm but are concerned about their privacy, otherwise you’d see more five star reviews. Since my own experience was a breath of fresh air, I feel compelled to write one to equalize some of the emotionally charged negative reviews. If you treat your separation as a business transaction that requires an equitable, efficient resolution, Robin is the person to bring both sides to the table with clarity. For that, I give her a fifteen (15) out of 5. My case involved significant financial complexity (stocks, various deferred compensation plans, cryptocurrency, collectibles, and two residences). I deeply appreciated Robin’s financial literacy and understanding of the tax implications tied to these assets. She also had the skills to handle the difficult dynamic between different attorneys; she commanded respect from both sides while demonstrating empathy and warmth from the very first conversation. Do yourself a favor and avoid litigation; it’s just an overpriced way to get to the same resolution Robin can help you come to more quickly. My recommendation: Instead of relying on the emotional venting you see here, ask the firm directly for verified testimonials from actual clients. There is a much clearer picture of their competence available if you simply ask for it. Robin Carton is an excellent mediator who can help you craft a resolution that allows you to start the next chapter of your lives.
read moreread less
I would give zero stars if possible. David literally walked out of custody hearing as I was fighting for my children because I wouldn’t pay him an obscene premium. He is not considered with fighting for you or your childrens rights. He’s business plan is to eat up your retainer and ask for more money. He was to be appointed by the judge, but then he could not accept retainer. So, he tried bullying me into money before the hearing. When I refused, he walked out and left me unrepresented. PROCEED WOTH CAUTION. ITS YOUR MONEY, NOT YOUR INTERESTS THAT HE IS WORKING FOR. Don’t say me and all the other reviews here didn’t warn you when you are 6 months into your custody battle , you’ve gotten no where and he has eaten up your retainer and is asking for more money. You read it here, don’t cry later.
read moreread less
Rosoff was my children's attorney, but I quickly realized that he was unprofessional and prejudiced, possibly even racist. He sided with the father's allegations against the mother and manipulated anything the children told him to benefit the father. I was shocked when I overheard Rosoff making derogatory remarks about the children's mother. It is clear that he is not fit to be a children's attorney. I recently discovered that Rosoff has been replaced by his wife or partner, Carton. However, I have little hope that Carton will be any different than Rosoff. I fear that she will continue to poorly represent the children, just like her husband did.
read moreread less
No reviews match these filters.
Use the filters above to see more reviews.
Related Attorneys
New York attorney registration
Record matched to the official New York attorney registry
AMANDA CARTON FRIED
ActiveBar #4432753
ROBIN DALE CARTON
ActiveBar #1846195
Last verified October 29, 2026.
Source: New York public attorney records. No affiliation or endorsement.
Monday
9 AM - 5 PM
Tuesday
9 AM - 5 PM
Wednesday
9 AM - 5 PM
Thursday
9 AM - 5 PM
Friday
9 AM - 5 PM
SaturdayClosed
SundayClosed
Is this your profile?
Claim your listing to manage your information, respond to reviews, and connect with potential clients.
Own or work here?
Claim Now!
Claim Now!
Want to report this? Report Now!

