About the Attorney

Tolbert & Tolbert LLC is a law firm and mediation service located in Gary, Indiana, serving clients in Northwest Indiana. The team at Tolbert & Tolbert is dedicated to providing top-notch legal representation and achieving the best possible resolution for each client. Specializing in litigation, personal injury, mediation, and business law, the attorneys at Tolbert & Tolbert have the experience and expertise to handle a wide range of legal matters. Whether you are facing a personal injury case or need assistance with business law issues, Tolbert & Tolbert is here to help. Contact them today for a consultation and find out how they can assist you with your legal needs in Gary, Indiana, and beyond.

Practice Areas

Personal injury attorney

Client Reviews

James Valentine

3/19/2026

Excellent legal service provided by Mike Tolbert. Thank you for your outstanding professionalism and sound legal advice.

Connect Paradise

3/17/2026

I had a consultation with Attorney Shelice Tolbert today, and I truly appreciated the experience. She was kind, attentive, and took the time to genuinely listen and understand my situation without rushing me.

What stood out most to me was her integrity. Rather than trying to take on something outside of her scope, she was honest and transparent in letting me know she wasn’t the best fit for my specific need. She then referred me to another attorney she felt confident could help, and even encouraged me to reach back out to her if that did not work out.

That level of honesty, professionalism, and care is rare. It showed me that she is not just focused on business, but on doing what is right for people.

If you are looking for an attorney in Northwest Indiana who values integrity, honesty, and truly puts people first, I highly recommend Attorney Shelice Tolbert.

Emily D. Edwards
Founder, Paradise®️