image
Attorney Portrait

Maynard, O’Connor, Smith & Catalinotto LLP

Is this your profile? Claim it

Legal services

Albany, New York
Law firm
3.7 - 6 Reviews

Contact Information

Practice Areas Reported by Attorneys at This Office

These areas come from individual attorney profiles and may not describe every service offered by the firm.

Client Reviews

Bill Williams Avatar
Bill Williams
9/10/2026
I had no personal business or legal matter with this firm and was not involved in their client’s property issues or dispute. Despite that, I was contacted by Justin Gray and asked to come into the office to speak with them regarding a legal issue with one of his clients home but would not go into detail. It was framed in a way that made it seem like I was involved in whatever legal issue they were exploring and made it sound serious. Although confused, I took time off from work and spent nearly two hours dealing with this, including a significant amount of time waiting in the lobby. When I was finally brought into an office, I was asked a series of questions about my property and whether I had experienced any problems with work or the quality of work performed. After approximately 15 minutes of questions, I finally asked why I had been contacted and why I was there. I repeatedly explained that I had no involvement in their client’s dispute, did not live next to the client, and had no idea why my information had been obtained or why I was being brought into the matter. Eventually, I was told that they apologized and that I did not actually need to come into the office. That was particularly frustrating after I had already taken time away from work and spent nearly two hours dealing with the situation. I found the experience with Justin Gray to be unnecessarily confusing, pushy, and unprofessional. I ultimately asked that I not be contacted again regarding the matter. If you are going to contact uninvolved people and ask them to take time off work to come to your office, I would expect the firm to first have a clear understanding of why they are being contacted and whether their involvement is actually necessary. Very disappointing experience.
read more
Yoda Avatar
Yoda
1/25/2026
I would not recommend this firm or its partners based on my experience. I interacted directly with Adam T. Mandell and Jessica Rounds, expecting professional, independent legal advocacy. Instead, I encountered dismissive communication, lack of transparency, and minimal engagement with the substance of my case. Serious concerns were raised and repeatedly downplayed rather than addressed. Representation felt procedural and detached, not client-focused. Questions about strategy, next steps, and obligations were met with resistance instead of clear explanations. At no point did I feel confident that my interests were being actively protected or prioritized. Billing and representation terms also raised concerns. Fees were discussed without sufficient explanation, and requests for clarity were not meaningfully answered. Trust is essential in an attorney-client relationship, and that trust was not established here. Given the firm’s affiliation with Maynard, O’Connor, Smith & Catalinotto, LLP, I expected a higher standard of professionalism and accountability. Unfortunately, that standard was not met. I strongly advise others to do thorough research, ask detailed questions upfront, and carefully evaluate alternative counsel before retaining this firm or its partners.
read more
Rose Herchenroeder Avatar
Rose Herchenroeder
12/24/2021
If you are looking for a real estate lawyer I cannot recommend Bridget Schultz enough. We had many issues with closing on our house from the sellers and she did a fantastic job navigating those issues and being extremely transparent with me and where we were at in the process. She did everything possible to make sure that we would be covered legally when we finally got to close on our home. She was also very responsive to any emails or phone calls which I also greatly appreciated.
read more
Pete Lomanto Avatar
Pete Lomanto
4/10/2021
read more
John Rogowicz Avatar
John Rogowicz
8/06/2020
read more

New York attorney registration

Record matched to the official New York attorney registry

KAREN ANN BUTLER

Active

Bar #2726545

KELLY MICHAEL MONROE

Active

Bar #4308482

ROBERT ANDREW RAUSCH

Active

Bar #2659068

Last verified October 29, 2026.

Source: New York public attorney records. No affiliation or endorsement.

Is this your profile?

Claim your listing to manage your information, respond to reviews, and connect with potential clients.

Want to report this? Report Now!

image