Attorney Toby Kinsler/Wisconsin Family Lawyers, S.C.

From my very first phone consultation with Toby Kinsler, I knew I had found the right attorney. He listened to my story, asked questions, and walked me through his process. When he agreed to take my case, I felt an immediate sense of relief. This was far from a typical divorce. It involved a restraining order, child safety concerns, complex financial issues including inheritance and investment accounts, a home, and reaching out to a neurotic, wayward ex whose documented behavior created an incredibly difficult and emotionally draining situation.

Even with all these complexities, Toby was incredibly thorough, prepared, and organized. He took the time to explain everything in a way that was easy to understand and never left me guessing. Whenever we discussed an issue, he would lay out the possible outcomes: Option A, Option B, or Option C, explaining what he believed was the most likely outcome, while also preparing me for the best- and worst-case scenarios. He never sugarcoated anything or made promises he couldn’t keep, but I always knew what to expect and why. If I found myself worrying, it was because of the circumstances, not because he hadn’t prepared me.

One of the things that truly set him apart was his accessibility. Toby was always available when I needed him. He responded to my emails and text messages incredibly quickly, and I never felt like I was left waiting or wondering. Having that level of communication during such a stressful time made all the difference.

I also appreciated that he is a one-attorney practice. From start to finish, I worked directly with him. Not an associate, not a paralegal handling important decisions, and not a revolving door of different attorneys trying to catch up on my case. He knew every detail because he personally handled every aspect of it. That continuity gave me tremendous confidence and made the entire process feel much more personal.

Something I appreciated most was how carefully he handled the sensitive aspects of my case. There were delicate matters involving my children, serious safety concerns, and behavior that required immediate action and meticulous documentation. He knew exactly how to organize, preserve, and present the evidence, making sure nothing important was overlooked. His preparation and attention to detail left no loose ends, and I always felt confident that my case was being handled with the urgency and care it deserved.

Toby was professional, compassionate, non-judgmental, strategic, and genuinely invested in protecting both me and my children, along with my assets. Because of his preparation, dedication, and hard work, my divorce was ultimately granted, exactly the way he planned it. The outcome I had first discussed and hoped for is exactly what I got. I will always be grateful that he was the attorney standing beside me through one of the most difficult times of my life. His hard work and success allowed me to release all the toxic baggage and move forward in life without having to look over my shoulder worried.

If you’re looking for an attorney who is honest, incredibly knowledgeable, detail-oriented, responsive, and willing to take on even the most difficult and complex cases, I cannot recommend Toby Kinsler highly enough. I feel incredibly fortunate that he accepted my case and WON! THANK YOU!

Highly recommend Toby for anyone going through the divorce process. He was able to review and assist with the mediation process and made things much easier to present and understand. Meeting was quick and efficient!

Toby did a spectacular job with a restraining order and contempt cases with my high conflict ex. He is very responsive and knowledgeable. His rates are very fair and much more affordable than other attorneys out there. My issues would not have been resolved without him!

Toby was amazing! Going through a divorce is gut-wrenching. When my world was crashing down, Toby was my rock. Having him in your corner gives you confidence. I'm not sure how many clients he deals with at the same time, but he makes you feel like you are his only one. He is knowledgeable, professional, and caring. I wouldn't want anyone else by my side.

Toby was a incredible family lawyer. He fought for me throughout my case, even when I did not want to. Toby is respectful, intelligent and hard working. Toby goes above and beyond his job description even when he doesn't have to. Toby is also a authentic person and truly cares about people. Wisconsin Family Lawyers was able to quickly resolve my case and come to fair terms, you want Toby on your side!